Attorney at Graves McLain Injury Lawyers

Practice Areas: Car Accidents, Medical Malpractice, Vaccine Injuries

Losing a loved one is always painful. But when that loss happens in a military hospital—and the family can’t even sue—it adds a new layer of frustration and injustice. That’s precisely what happened in the case of Navy Lieutenant Rebekah Daniel, whose wrongful death became a national example of how current laws limit legal rights for active-duty military families.

In this post, we explore whether it’s possible to sue the military or federal government for wrongful death, how the Feres Doctrine stands in the way, and what legal options do or don’t exist under federal law.

What Is the Feres Doctrine?

The Feres Doctrine is a legal rule that stops active-duty military personnel from suing the federal government for injuries or deaths that happen during service. It came from the 1950 Supreme Court case Feres v. United States, which involved three different military-related injuries and fatalities.

The Court ruled that the government isn’t liable for harm caused by other service members while someone is on active duty. The idea was that the military already offers support systems like pensions and survivor benefits and that allowing lawsuits would interfere with discipline and command.

In Feres v. United States (1950), the U.S. Supreme Court held that the government is not liable for injuries to servicemembers that arise out of or are in the course of activity incident to service.

Since then, the Feres Doctrine has been used to dismiss thousands of lawsuits involving military medical malpractice—even when the alleged negligence is severe or fatal.

The Rebekah Daniel Case: A Closer Look

Rebekah Daniel was a 33-year-old Navy nurse who died from severe bleeding just hours after giving birth at Naval Hospital Bremerton in Washington in 2014. Her husband, former Coast Guard officer Walter Daniel, filed a wrongful death lawsuit in 2015. He argued that Rebekah’s death was the result of poor care—not an unavoidable complication.

His case was dismissed under the Feres Doctrine, and every appeal failed. Finally, he petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to reconsider the doctrine and allow exceptions in cases involving medical negligence.

Lieutenant Rebekah Daniel’s case became a national symbol of the constraints placed by the Feres Doctrine, especially in cases involving preventable medical deaths.

The Supreme Court declined to hear the case in 2019, once again leaving the doctrine untouched.

Can You Sue the Military or Federal Government for Wrongful Death?

Many people are surprised to learn that while civilians can sue the government under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), active-duty service members cannot do so for injuries or deaths related to military service. This includes deaths in military hospitals caused by alleged medical malpractice.

The Feres Doctrine has long prevented active-duty service members from seeking justice through the courts—even when harmed by medical negligence in military hospitals.

That said, there are some exceptions. For example, civilian family members or military dependents harmed in military hospitals may be able to sue. Veterans may also have some legal options depending on their discharge status and the timing of the injury.

In contrast, service members on active duty are almost always barred from filing these lawsuits, no matter how clear the negligence may seem.

Table: Civilian vs. Military Wrongful Death Claims

Category

Civilian Family

Active-Duty Military Family

Legal PathState wrongful death statuteBlocked by Feres Doctrine
Can Sue the Federal Government?Yes, under FTCANo, if incident to service
Access to Jury TrialYesNo
Can Sue Military Hospital?Yes (if civilian harmed)No (if service member harmed)
Time Limit to File2 years (varies by state)Not applicable

Arguments for and Against Reform

Many legal experts, lawmakers, and veterans advocates believe the Feres Doctrine is outdated. They argue that military families deserve the same right to hold the government accountable, especially in medical malpractice cases where poor care leads to death or long-term harm.

Proponents of reform say the doctrine:

  • Removes the right to seek justice.
  • Hides problems in the military healthcare system.
  • Denies families compensation they would be entitled to in civilian courts.

Opponents argue that changing the rule could:

  • Leading to a flood of lawsuits.
  • Disrupt military order and discipline.
  • Encourage court reviews of combat decisions.

Groups like Protect Our Defenders continue to advocate for legal changes that would allow some lawsuits in medical negligence cases.

Wrongful Death Rights Outside the Military

Oklahoma law allows surviving family members to file when a loved one passes away; a wrongful death claim is filed due to another’s negligence. These lawsuits often involve car crashes, medical errors, workplace accidents, and other preventable events.

In Oklahoma, eligible family members can seek damages for:

  • Medical and funeral expenses
  • Loss of income and benefits
  • Pain and suffering
  • Loss of companionship

The statute of limitations is typically two years from the date of death. While active-duty military deaths are blocked under Feres, civilian casualties are not. If your loved one died because of someone else’s actions—and they were not on active military duty—you may have legal options worth exploring.

FAQs

Can I sue the military for wrongful death if my spouse was on active duty?

Generally, no, if the death was related to their military service. The Feres Doctrine blocks such claims. Legal exceptions are limited and still under debate.

What is the Feres Doctrine, and how does it impact wrongful death lawsuits?

It’s a 1950 Supreme Court ruling that prevents service members from suing the federal government for injuries or deaths that occur while on active duty.

Can military families sue for medical malpractice at military hospitals?

If the patient is an active-duty member, the answer is usually no due to Feres. Dependents or retirees may be able to sue under certain conditions.

Has the Supreme Court ever reconsidered the Feres Doctrine?

Yes, but not successfully. The Court declined to reverse the doctrine in 1987 and again in later petitions, including the Daniel case.

What can families of service members do if they believe negligence occurred?

They can report the issue through military channels or advocacy groups, but civil legal action is limited. Some may pursue legislative reform efforts.

Are wrongful death lawsuits against government agencies ever allowed?

Yes, under the FTCA—but not for injuries or deaths tied directly to military service due to Feres.

Contact Our Firm &
Request a Free Case Review

Conclusion

The tragic death of Lieutenant Rebekah Daniel brought national attention to a legal rule many Americans had never heard of—the Feres Doctrine. Her family’s fight for accountability revealed just how difficult it is for active-duty service members to seek justice, even when harmed by negligence.

For civilian families dealing with wrongful death, the law does offer a path forward. Graves McLain Injury Lawyers helps families in Oklahoma navigate these complex cases, understand their rights, and pursue compensation when it’s available. If you’ve lost a loved one and wonder what your legal options might be, it’s worth having that conversation.

When injury victims need a law firm with a reputation for excellence, turn to Graves McLain Injury Lawyers. We are a top-rated personal injury firm determined to be the best. With decades of award-winning representation, our clients recover the compensation they need to put their lives back together.

  • I knew my auto accident wouldn’t be worth much and they knew it too but worked as if it was a million dollar case and kept me informed hope I never need an attorney again but if I do it’ll be graves mclain I brag on them to everyone

    Margie C

  • The staff is great and super friendly. They helped me get the money I deserved. I would definitely recommend them to everyone!

    CiCi H

  • My orthopedic doctor recommended Graves McLain Injury Lawyers, PLLC, to me following the need for revision hip surgery due to a hip from Stryker that was putting poison into my system. The doctor took care of the hip, and Graves McLain Injury Lawyers, PLLC, took care of the legal case. They were very thorough, professional, courteous, and always ready to answer the questions I had throughout the length of the case. In a word, the entire office is fantastic. I’m sure they were tired of my inquiries on the case’s progress, but they did not show it. They were always willing to respond and were very positive. If I ever have a claim in the future, they will be the first group to whom I reach out.

    Robert S.

Contact Our Firm &
Request a Free Case Review